OC CIO Roundtable Minutes 8-13-09

Southern California/Orange County CIO Breakfast Round Table
August 13, 2009 meeting

Present: Carmella Cassetta, Tina Haines, Jim Sutter, Jeff Reid, Sharon Solomon, Sean Brown, Dave Phillips

The minutes of this and prior breakfasts are available online at the Peer Consulting Group’s website, www.peergroup.net, with links to the presentation material, when available. Carmella introduced this topic by conference call from Toronto, where she was attending a meeting at one of her regional centers.

Topic: ERP Implementations – lessons learned.

Carmella Cassetta, Corinthian Colleges, began by doing a situation analysis – 106 locations, 3 regional centers (Toronto, Tampa, and Santa Ana), growing through acquisition, $1-1.5 B revenue, 10,000 employees, 7 different systems and technical environments, no data standards, past ERP implementations failed. She summarized the reasons for an ERP – common information flow throughout the organization, effectiveness, efficiency, lower TCO, organizational alignment, optimized business processes, integrated financials, technical obsolescence. It was a $45M investment, but she had executive commitment, support and participation, without which any ERP implementation will fail, and a business strategy and discipline to align BP changes to match a vanilla package implementation. Other common reasons for failure include poor project management, poor estimates of time and resource requirements, not cleaning inconsistent data prior to implementation, cultural rejection, poor change management, inadequate training, and customizing the software. Because of these, the stats show 35% of ERP projects are cancelled, and only 10% are completed on time and within budget. To ensure success, identify each CSF and develop a plan to support each of them. For example, identify the project as a business driven project (not an IT project) by identifying the executive sponsor, creating a cross-functional team to formulate business needs up-front and identify the strategic priorities, and to support the changes in company culture, structure and processes. CCI’s ERP project was named UNIFY. Carmella has several slides on other CSFs, including a Gartner one which suggested accepting “best practice” ERP for your industry (in CCI’s case, CAMPUSVIEW), and minimize customizations. CCI’s approach did many things right, including tying success to business bonus and performance plans. She has several slides in her handout detailing the UNIFY project in its 3 phases, the role of the executive oversight committee, and the PMO. She hired a consulting company, PRTM, to help her with the project organization and structure, and to support CCI throughout the 3-year implementation. I thoroughly recommend that you review the handout and the slides on CCI’s approach. To summarize, Carmella shared with us some lessons learned at this stage of the project – 60% complete, 40 sites to convert over the next 6-8 months, within 10% of original budget, schedule delay of 6 months waiting on software enhancements. The organization is responding well, with several keys to success. The hardest parts include getting the right balance of training (before and after installation), don’t underestimate the difficulties of change, waiting on customization, maintaining good communications and business alignment over 3 years, and keeping to the cost estimates. Her slides are at: http://www.slideshare.net/occio/cio-council-erp-update-081309 .

Tina Haines congratulated Carmella on an excellent presentation, and on her leadership throughout the project. Tina has been involved with implementing ERP systems 4 times, with probably the most successful being one centralized in Singapore, supporting 40 business units and 110K employees. She recently was involved with converting a UK company into the US system, using in-country resources, which became a problem because they wanted to optimize the system.

Jim Sutter, Peer Consulting, complimented Carmella on a very good presentation and project. He suggested that CCI offer a course on Project Management, focusing on ERP implementation best practices. Many years ago, before they had the benefit of best practices, Rockwell tended to “learn as we go”. His Winery client used the ERP implementation to try to unify the company, which were historically split in two. They selected the JD Edwards system as the base system, but the project was nowhere near as well managed as CCI’s. They allowed many modifications to be made to the order entry system. They also wanted best of breed solutions for other systems. Three years ago, they dropped maintenance and now are starting to inch closer to Oracle’s ERP.

Jeff Reid thought the presentation was excellent, and wished he had listened to it before he started his first implementation. Many companies go through agonies with an ERP project. He noted that PRTM worked out well for them. He will use this as a checklist for his next ERP implementation project.

Sharon Solomon also complimented Carmella on a great presentation and project leadership. Support from the top down is very important. She remembers her first ERP project – they were 10 months into the project when another company acquired them, and she was selected to be on the N. A. leadership group for the implementation. She made sure it was business driven, and that they developed an effective monthly communications meeting because the rumor mill can be very destructive. When they acquired another company, they were able to convert them very quickly to the new ERP system, working closely with top management.

Sean Brown, RJTCompuquest, thought the presentation was excellent and he took lots of notes. Enhancements to Campus View did cause problems. Getting the users to be part of the selection process is important. He remembers working for an Asian company whose philosophy was “change or be beheaded”. He agrees that its important to find a partner to help manage the project, use best practices, and to help with change management – they have used Sharepoint to help them do change management.

Thanks again to Carmella for an excellent introduction and handout.