OC CIO Roundtable Minutes 10-8-09

1993-2009
Southern California/Orange County CIO Breakfast Round Table
October 8, 2009 meeting

Present: Tina Haines, Jennifer Curlee, Sean Brown, Jeff Reid, William Zauner,
Jim Sutter

The minutes of this and prior breakfasts are available online at the Peer Consulting Group’s website, www.peergroup.net, with links to the presentation material, when available.

We are still looking for volunteers to introduce the following topics, starting in January:
IT alignment with the CEO/business
IT Governance
Web 2.0/Web 3.0
On-demand computing
Go Green with ?
Service Catalog
CIO longevity (or lack thereof)

Topic: IT Organization Trends

Tina Haines, Meggitt Electronics, introduced the meeting and provided a comprehensive handout. Tina provided significant background on organizational thinking and OD thinking. Quotes from Andy Grove, Peter Drucker, Parkinson, and Werner von Braun spiced the material. Elements of OD theory affect:
Behavior
Motivation
Performance
Teamwork and cooperation
And, inter organization relationships.
She pointed out that despite all the organization styles defined and adopted over the years, most still tend to be quite hierarchical. She gave the pros and cons of the hierarchical, matrix, flat, and federated approaches. She led a discussion on decentralization verses centralization, followed by some thoughts on 21st Century trends (Globalization, Diversity, and Flexibility). She pointed out that best practices were difficult to nail down, despite efforts by ITIL and others. Some laws to guide us in the New Rapidly Changing environment:
If you understand it, it’s obsolete.
Strategy: If it’s static, it’s obsolete.
Training: If it’s certified, it’s obsolete.
Understandably, a discussion followed.

Future workforce dynamics were examined that supported material presented in prior meeting regarding the changing demographics and the expectations of Gen Y entrants in the workforce. Among the statistics Tina cited: “there is a huge amount of expertise walking out of the economy. In 2010, 3 people will leave the economy for every person that enters it; by 2012, 4. By 2016, 6 people will leave for every new worker that joins. These are staggering realities”. More lively discussion.

Tina reported on the results of her recent survey of Peer Group members. Sixty-two (62) percent report to the CEO. A fine presentation and excellent handout material. Thanks Tina.

William Zauner, JAMS, commented that his organization is a combination of Federated and Flat. He underscored the longevity that he and his fellow executives have and the resulting trust and cooperation that characterizes JAMS. The issues he deals with have to due with resource limitations and responding to aggressive ideas of independent lawyers and their technology initiatives.

Jenifer Curlee, Surefire, described her portfolio management approach to organizing IT work. The resources are organized by function within the business. She co-locates IT resources in these functions and sets tight architectural standards and guidelines. Given the various priorities of different areas of the business, significant negotiation is an on going part of the job.

Jeff Reid, formerly of Conexant/Toyota, pointed out that he has experienced all flavors of the organizational styles described. He has reported to the CFO, and the CIO. He has seen companies get flatter as they are forced to reduce size. Throughout, the key to success and effective operation is trust, mutual respect, and relationship building.

Jim Sutter, Peer Consulting Group, in his consulting work, has dealt mostly with IT organizations that were highly centralized and stated that this seems to be a trend in leading companies. Rockwell operated in four very distinct industries, providing significant challenges in providing corporate IT services and governance.

Thanks, again, to Tina Haines for leading a top-notch discussion. Tina's slides are at http://www.slideshare.net/occio .